Mystery Books
227 books across every collection, listed once each — books on several lists come first.
Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
On 7 lists: Female Detective Books·Female Protagonists ·Highly Rated Crime·Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010)·Highly Rated Mystery·Highly Rated Thriller·Thrillers
Demon Copperhead
On 6 lists: Best Summer Reads 2025·Highly Rated Books ·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Literary Fiction·Oprah Book Club·Top Book Club 2024
Remarkably Bright Creatures
On 6 lists: Best Summer Reads 2025·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Mystery·Most Popular Books of Past Decade·Top Book Club·Top Book Club 2024
House Of Leaves
On 5 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (Before 2010)·Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010) ·Highly Rated Horror·Highly Rated Mystery·Highly Rated Thriller
In Cold Blood
On 5 lists: Highly Rated Classics·Highly Rated Crime ·Highly Rated Mystery·Highly Rated Thriller·The Classics
The Library At Mount Char
On 5 lists: Best Fantasy Books·Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Horror·Highly Rated Mystery
The Will Of The Many
On 4 lists: Highly Rated Books·Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Science Fiction
The Lies Of Locke Lamora
On 4 lists: Best Fantasy Books·Highly Rated Books ·Highly Rated Fantasy (Before 2010)·Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010)
Big Little Lies
On 4 lists: Best Summer Reads 2025·Highly Rated Mystery ·Highly Rated Thriller·Top Book Club
The Shadow Of The Wind
On 4 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (Before 2010)·Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010) ·Highly Rated Historical Fiction·Highly Rated Mystery
All Systems Red
On 4 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Mystery·Highly Rated Science Fiction
Gideon The Ninth
On 4 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Mystery·Highly Rated Science Fiction
No Country For Old Men
On 4 lists: Highly Rated Crime·Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010) ·Highly Rated Literary Fiction·Highly Rated Thriller
The Housemaid
On 4 lists: Best Summer Reads 2025·Thrillers ·Top Book Club·Top Book Club 2024
A Short History Of Nearly Everything
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Books·Highly Rated History ·Highly Rated Non-fiction
And Then There Were None
On 3 lists: Classic Crime, Mystery, and Thrillers·The Classics ·Thrillers
Anxious People
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Literary Fiction ·Top Book Club
City Of Stairs
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Mystery ·Highly Rated Science Fiction
Shutter Island
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Fiction (Before 2010)·Highly Rated Thriller ·Thrillers
Under The Whispering Door
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Romance
Razorblade Tears
On 3 lists: Best Summer Reads 2025·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Thriller
The Dispatcher
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Crime·Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards) ·Highly Rated Science Fiction
The Mountain In The Sea
On 3 lists: Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Science Fiction ·Top Sci Fi Books
The Wager: A Tale Of Shipwreck, Mutiny And Murder
On 2 lists: Highly Rated History·Highly Rated Mystery
Ninth House
On 2 lists: Highly Rated Fantasy (2010 Onwards)·Highly Rated Fiction (2010 Onwards)
The Murder Of Roger Ackroyd
On 2 lists: Classic Crime, Mystery, and Thrillers·Female Detective Books
Crocodile On The Sandbank
On 2 lists: Classic Crime, Mystery, and Thrillers·Female Detective Books
Drive Your Plow Over The Bones Of The Dead
On 2 lists: Duo Lipa Book Club·Natalie Portman's Book Club
