Between Two Fires Book Club Questions
10 discussion questions for Between Two Fires by Christopher Buehlman.
October 18, 2026
Spoiler warning: some questions touch on how the book ends. Best read after you've finished it.
Discussion questions
- What were your initial impressions of Thomas when he first encountered the young girl in the Norman village?
- How did the setting of the Black Death enhance the horror elements of the story?
- In what ways does the young girl's vision of the angels change Thomas's perspective on his past and his future?
- Do you think Thomas's decision to believe the girl's visions was wise, or was he driven more by desperation?
- Discuss the significance of Avignon as the destination for Thomas and the girl's journey. What does it represent in the context of their mission?
- How did Buehlman's portrayal of the fallen angels and their war on heaven challenge or reaffirm your understanding of angelic lore?
- What was your reaction to the reveal of the girl's true nature? Did it alter your perception of her character?
- How does the structure of the novel, with its blend of historical fiction and fantasy, affect the pacing and mood of the story?
- Can you relate any part of Thomas's journey or transformation to a personal experience of seeking redemption or a new beginning?
- What did you think of the ending? Did it provide closure, or were there aspects left unresolved that you wish had been addressed?
These questions were drafted with AI help for book clubs using Lapwing.
Reading Between Two Fires with your book club?
Lapwing keeps your club's reading list, votes and meeting dates in one place, free. Members pick the dates that suit them, and the book everyone wants rises to the top.
Start your book club
